Posts by Topic:

Action

Court of Public Opinion

Duplicity

General

Guest Bloggers

Hard to Believe

Health Care

High Costs

Humor

In The News

In Your Community

Notes From The Road

On the road

Real Facts

By Date: Blogroll: Links:

Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Wal-Mart Chief Bought Ring From Firm's Vendor

Here is the latest story in the growing ethics scandal involving Wal-Mart CEO Lee Scott. As the article later states, "Supplying a diamond ring for a chief executive's wife would appear an unusual order for The Aaron Group, which on its Web site describes itself as a "maker of popular priced" jewelry."

From The Wall Street Journal:

Wal-Mart Stores Inc. Chief Executive H. Lee Scott, who recently was accused by a fired marketing executive of accepting sweetheart deals from suppliers, purchased a diamond ring from a Wal-Mart vendor, according to that vendor's officials.

Mr. Scott purchased the ring for his wife in April 2003 from The Aaron Group, a wholesale supplier of jewelry to Wal-Mart, said Robert Kempler, president of the New York-based company. Mr. Kempler declined to discuss the terms of the diamond sale other than to say Mr. Scott hadn't received preferential pricing.

Wal-Mart's famously strict ethics code prohibits employees from receiving anything free from suppliers. Last week, Julie Roehm, a former Wal-Mart marketing executive who was fired in December for allegedly violating the retailer's ethics rules, claimed in a federal court filing that Mr. Scott obtained "a number of yachts" and "a large pink diamond" at preferential prices.

The lawsuit didn't identify the specifics of the diamond sale, other than to say that Mr. Scott had purchased the stone through a relationship with Irwin Jacobs, a financier who has numerous business relationships with Wal-Mart. It isn't clear whether the diamond ring purchased from The Aaron Group is the same one referred to in Ms. Roehm's suit.

Mr. Kempler said he'd never heard of Mr. Jacobs, and he said everything about the transaction was "above board." Mr. Jacobs called the allegations without any substance and has denied knowing anything about any diamond purchase by the Wal-Mart CEO.

A Wal-Mart spokeswoman declined to comment specifically on the diamond purchase or Wal-Mart's policies on employee purchases from suppliers. Mr. Scott "is subject to the same ethics policy as any other associate and has not violated either the spirit or the letter of Wal-Mart's ethical standards," the spokeswoman said. She characterized the allegations in Ms. Roehm's court filing as "old news. No facts have been presented to back them up."

Charles Elson, Director of the John L. Weinberg Center for Corporate Governance at the University of Delaware, said Mr. Scott shouldn't have been doing business with any vendor, even if the deal was in accordance with Wal-Mart's ethics rules. "Someone at that level, at that paygrade, should avoid dealing with the company vendors," Mr. Elson said. "It sends the absolute wrong signal to the rest of the organization, particularly one that prides itself on its relationships with vendors."

Wal-Mart's code of ethics prohibits employees from requesting or encouraging gifts from suppliers, including "free goods...personal services or favors" or "kickbacks in the form of money or merchandise." It doesn't specifically bar employees from purchasing goods from suppliers, but it does advise more broadly: "Do not have social or other relationships with suppliers, if such relationships would create the appearance of impropriety or give the perception that business influence is being exerted."

In court filings, Bentonville, Ark., Wal-Mart previously had accused Ms. Roehm of having an improper personal relationship with a subordinate and improperly accepting gifts from suppliers, including liquor and lavish dinners. She has denied accepting gifts and insisted suppliers were told to bill the company for any meals. In the increasingly bitter fight, Ms. Roehm has accused the company of a double standard, detailing instances in which other top executives supposedly received favors from suppliers.

Supplying a diamond ring for a chief executive's wife would appear an unusual order for The Aaron Group, which on its Web site describes itself as a "maker of popular priced" jewelry. The company says its "target focus is the middle market consumer" with retail jewelry from $29.99 to $999. Among its retailing partners it says, are Wal-Mart and its Sam's Club unit; JC Penney Co.; and Kohl's Corp.

Posted by Sascha - May 31, 2007 10:08 AM - In The News